A safety net is a moral commitment. We tell taxpayers their money will help people who truly need it, and we tell those people help is coming. Fraud breaks both halves of that promise at once.
In Milwaukee, the promise has been broken for years, and the results are devastating. The prenatal care coordination program exists within Medicaid to guide low-income pregnant women to medical and counseling services. It operates in a city where an average of 78 babies a year died before their first birthday between 2019 and 2022, and where Black infants were three times as likely to die as white infants. If any program deserved careful stewardship, this one did.
Last week the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported three more people facing federal charges, with four others pleading guilty in recent months. More than a dozen owners, employees and associates have now been charged since 2022, with tens of millions of taxpayer dollars being lost to this fraud, and zero true prenatal services being provided.
More than a dozen owners, employees and associates have now been charged since 2022, with tens of millions of taxpayer dollars being lost to this fraud, and zero true prenatal services being provided.
The allegations are ugly. Detra Ferguson of Direct Care Prenatal is accused of luring clients with cash and free baby supplies and billing Medicaid for services never provided. The indictment says Medicaid paid her business more than $2 million it was not entitled to. LaTonya Baker, a co-owner of Generation of Excellence, and employee Grisel Delgado are accused of billing schemes that allegedly drew more than $9.4 million. Other defendants have pleaded guilty. Candy Gandy of Bundle of Love agreed to forfeit $5.4 million, along with three custom Rolex watches and jewelry. Precious Cruse, Markita Barnes and LaKia Jackson are already serving prison sentences.
Federal prosecutors deserve credit here for aggressively prosecuting these cases.
Unfortunately, taxpayer funded programs like this that pay first and ask questions later invites exactly this behavior. When the main test of whether a provider is serving people is whether it submits bills, the most aggressive billers win and the most honest providers lose. “Community baby showers” collected mothers’ Medicaid numbers for fake claims.
Wisconsin’s Medicaid program is projected to cost $36.4 billion over the 2025-27 budget, nearly one-third of the state budget. Whether state or federal funding, these are taxpayer dollars that are meant to help the most vulnerable. Aid should go first to those who truly can’t provide for themselves: children, pregnant women, the disabled and the elderly. Taking advantage of taxpayers by faking prenatal services is perhaps to most egregious of Medicaid fraud. To be so careless about pregnant mothers and their children to defraud care that is set up to improve health outcomes deserves the highest level of scrutiny, prosecution and accountability.
To be so careless about pregnant mothers and their children to defraud care that is set up to improve health outcomes deserves the highest level of scrutiny, prosecution and accountability.
Programs should reward results rather than paperwork. Able-bodied adults without young children should be expected to work or prepare for work in exchange for public help, and Wisconsin voters have said so: a 2023 advisory referendum, 80 percent of Wisconsin voters supported work requirements for that group. Every dollar lost to fraud or handed to someone who doesn’t need it is a dollar that can’t reach someone who does.
Wisconsinites should demand a close review of every program that spends public money on vulnerable residents, not just prenatal care coordination. Two simple questions should guide every review. Is the program reaching and helping the people it was built for? Are taxpayers dollars being put to good use?
Compassion without accountability is not compassion at all. Mothers and babies, and the taxpayers who fund this program, deserve both.
