The Racine County Sheriff’s Office confirmed Wednesday that Capt. Cary Madrigal remains on administrative leave in connection with an allegation related to the investigation of Thomas Johnson, the Union Grove Union High School Superintendent charged with possession of child pornography.
The office said it learned on Nov. 6 of an allegation involving Madrigal related to the Johnson investigation. Sheriff Christopher Schmaling placed her on administrative leave the following day, Nov. 7, and requested that the Wisconsin Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation examine her alleged involvement. The request was made to preserve the integrity of the investigation into Johnson, according to the office. The Racine County Sheriff’s Office plans to conduct a separate internal administrative review of Madrigal’s actions once the state investigation is complete.
Officials have reiterated that Madrigal is not the focus or subject of the criminal investigation into Johnson and that she has not been charged with any crimes. The leave is not related to the Nov. 3 election, in which Democrat Donald Vandervest defeated Madrigal for Racine County Sheriff.
Johnson, 51, was arrested Nov. 4 and charged in Kenosha County Circuit Court with two felony counts of possession of child pornography. He has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent unless and until convicted. The investigation began after the Racine County Sheriff’s Office received an anonymous letter on Oct. 22 alleging inappropriate communications and images involving Johnson with children. Racine County investigators interviewed Johnson the following day.
The case was referred to the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office on Oct. 27. Court filings state that Johnson told investigators someone from the Racine County Sheriff’s Office spoke with him in his office about the investigation before it had been formally assigned to investigators.
Racine County Board Chairman Tom Kramer told WISN 12 News the County Board voted unanimously Tuesday, Nov. 17 to move to release documents from another investigation tied to Madrigal. Kramer said the board called the meeting in response to pressure from constituents wanting to know more about Madrigal’s involvement in the investigation into Preston Kite.
In 2024, then-Deputy Preston Kite was arrested for exposing himself in a gas station; detectives found child porn on his phone. The county board said Madrigal was disciplined after that case “stemming from her response to allegations that another deputy received an inappropriate photo from Kite.” Kramer said, “Enough supervisors got enough calls from the community and we wanted to be as transparent as we could with this.” The move to release the documents will go to the full board for approval in December.
The Racine County Sheriff’s Office has not publicly detailed the specific nature of the allegation involving Madrigal. She has not publicly commented on the latest developments.
Madrigal, a 26-year veteran of the Racine County Sheriff’s Office who has served as captain of the operations division for about six years, finished roughly 2,400 votes behind Donald Vandervest in the Nov. 3 election.
The Sheriff’s Office has said it will not provide further comment at this time beyond the information in its statements.
