Wisconsin Superintendent Jill Underly defended the Department of Public Instruction’s changes to standardized test cut scores and school report cards this week, calling a new Legislative Audit Bureau report politically driven and factually wrong.
The audit, which was released Friday, found that DPI adjusted achievement scores on 2023-24 report cards so that no school or district’s score declined from the prior year, regardless of actual performance. Auditors said the agency replaced declining scores with the previous year’s figures for roughly 64% of schools in English language arts and 44% in math.
The report also flagged a lack of written policies for the changes, limited public input and questions about compliance with reporting requirements.
“Let’s be clear: Our job at the DPI is to do what’s best for Wisconsin’s kids and families,” she said on UPFRONT Sunday morning. “The Legislative Audit Bureau’s job is to conduct objective, fact-based audits, and not play politics.”
Underly claimed said the previous cut scores set an “extremely high standard to meet” that made students “appear to be doing worse than they really were.”
“This audit offers nothing new,” she added. “The DPI has been transparent throughout this process, participated in multiple public legislative hearings on these issues, and repeatedly answered questions about our work.
“Instead of providing meaningful new information and recommendations, the audit makes factually incorrect assertions, goes beyond the scope of its review, and reads like a continuation of last legislative session’s partisan political theater rather than a review conducted in good faith.”
The nonpartisan audit determined that “although certain schools appeared to experience decreases in student achievement in 2023-2024, which was counter to DPI’s expectation following its changes to academic assessment cut scores, DPI’s adjustment increased the student achievement scores for these schools and school districts.”
The Legislative Audit Bureau found that DPI did not have any written steps to determine how or why scores were adjusted, and when auditors requested “documentation of any steps DPI took to assess whether unadjusted school year 023-2024 student achievement scores for these schools and school districts may have indicated a decline in achievement compared to the prior year,” DPI admitted that it never conducted that sort of assessment.
“DPI indicated that it did not consider the use of a prior-year student achievement score to be an indication of a performance concern,” auditors concluded.
The audit was released just a day after DPI released the latest school and district report cards, which rated about 95% of public districts as meeting, exceeding or significantly exceeding expectations. It came less than a week after Underly requested $2.75 billion in additional state aid for the 2027-29 budget.
