Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announced Thursday he will not file criminal charges against Madison police officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson, who shot and killed Corey Ruiz during a struggle on the city’s near east side July 22.
In a written decision, Ozanne concluded it was “reasonable for the officer to use deadly force when this person resisted officers, produced a knife, and was not affected by multiple Taser attempts while officers tried to take him into custody.” His office found “no potential criminal court liability” for any officers involved.
The Associated Press described Baitinger-Peterson as a white officer and Ruiz, 38, as a Black man. Baitinger-Peterson did not reply to an AP email seeking comment.
Ozanne’s Reasoning
Ozanne’s release quoted Wisconsin’s self-defense statute, 939.48, in full, which he said is not his usual practice. The law allows force likely to cause death or great bodily harm only when a person reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to themselves or someone else.
“A person fleeing from police who, when contacted, physically resists and produces a knife from their person does pose a threat of great bodily harm and/or death to the officers,” Ozanne wrote. “Responding to that threat with deadly force is permitted under the law.”
He added, “A person does not have to like and/or agree with the law, however I am sworn to apply the law to the facts at hand. The law applies equally to members of law enforcement and to those who are not.”
Ozanne said he reviewed officer statements, scene diagrams, and video from squad cars, surveillance cameras, and bystanders’ phones and found the evidence “all consistent.” Madison city council refused to allow police to wear body cameras.
His evidence summary lays out what led to the shooting. Just after 12:40 p.m., a 911 caller reported someone tried to break into her home and rode off on one of the family’s bikes. A neighborhood officer identified the man on the homeowners’ Ring video as Ruiz, whom he knew from past contacts. Ruiz rode past officers who yelled “Police, Stop.” He was later seen on Willy Street Co-op cameras checking bikes at a rack. “No weapon was visible in Mr. Ruiz’s hands or on his person,” the summary says.
Near South Baldwin and Williamson streets, Ruiz tumbled off his bicycle when an officer made contact, according to the summary. Officers ordered him to “quit reaching in your waist” and tried to handcuff him. He pulled a knife, and an officer was heard saying “he’s got a knife” repeatedly. Two officers fired Tasers. Ruiz “fell or was taken to the ground just before three shots were fired,” hitting him twice, in the torso and head. Toxicology found methamphetamine, cocaine metabolites, and a presumptive positive for cannabinoids.
Family Responds
Ben Crump, the family’s attorney, said the videos Ozanne showed the family do not justify the shooting.
“There is nothing in the videos the district attorney showed us that justifies this officer stepping back, pulling his gun, and firing three shots at point-blank range at Corey Ruiz after he had been tased and was on the ground, hitting him once in the chest and with the kill shot to his head,” Crump said in a statement reported by WKOW. “The medical examiner told the family that if the officer had not fired that shot to his head, Corey would have survived.”
The family’s news conference at the Center for Black Excellence and Culture was pushed back to 1:30 p.m., reporter Elly Laliberte posted. Demonstrators gathered outside beforehand. Earlier, about 30 supporters rallied outside the Dane County Medical Examiner’s office in McFarland after the family’s meeting was moved there from Downtown Madison, the Wisconsin State Journal reported.
What Comes Next
The Madison Police Department said Thursday that all four officers remain on administrative leave. An internal review will follow the charging decision, WISN reported. The officers could return to duty after that review.
Ahead of the announcement, Channel 3000 reported police would work 12-hour shifts through Thanksgiving and set up an arrest-processing center, Heartland Post reported this morning.
Ozanne still must decide whether to charge former interim Independent Police Monitor Aeiramique Glass over an Aug. 4 confrontation with officers.
Background
The state Division of Criminal Investigation handled the case and sent its findings to Ozanne in late September. The shooting, recorded by bystanders, set off protests and an encampment at Williamson and Baldwin that police and city crews cleared Aug. 4. Madison officers did not wear body cameras, and the city has since moved up its rollout to the end of 2027. Channel 3000 reported Ruiz had 12 prior felony convictions.
