DPI just dropped its 2027-29 budget request. They call it “$2.75 billion” in new aid. The real ask is $5.29B, made to look smaller by wiping out the $1.275B/yr property tax credit on your bill. What is inside the budget is what will shock Wisconsin taxpayers.
Here’s what the request actually does to families.
Special Needs Scholarships
Special Needs Scholarship: DPI wants to phase it out. No new students or schools after 2027-28, and the “actual cost” option for high-need kids ends. No reason given. This is devastating for families whose kids were failed by their public school. That door slams shut to new students. This option is a lifeline currently for 3,859 students with 232 private schools participating, a year-over-year increase of +12% students.
School Choice
Every choice student would get a flat $12,552 frozen and the program’s automatic increases repealed. Choice high schoolers lose $1,247, down from $13,799 while public school districts get +$1,108 per pupil, then automatic inflation raises are written into law. DPI is signaling that every child is not worth an equal investment and they will be determining your child’s educational investment worth.
Mental Health
Lawmakers gave school mental health grants a one-time $30M boost. DPI calls quadrupling the base from $10M to $40M a “restore.” It rebrands it with Evers’ “Get Kids Ahead,” keeps private schools locked out, and rewrites the law so the money covers only kindergarten through 5th grade. Middle and high schoolers get written out of a program that serves every grade today. What’s left is aimed at “disruptive behaviors at school, as defined by the department by rule.” DPI gets to write its own definition.
Separately, DPI doubles the other mental-health aid program to $24M and asks that private schools no longer be eligible in FY28, with no reason given. DPI can’t even keep its story straight: one paragraph says choice schools “would continue” to be eligible, and the next says to “Remove private schools.” Same kids, same struggles, simply shut out.
Act 20 and Reading
Now Act 20. In 2023 the Legislature passed science of reading: approved curriculum, a ban on three-cueing, and required teacher training. DPI’s budget calls that law’s requirements “rigid” and goes around them. Act 20’s guarantee of literacy coaches in choice schools? Repealed. DPI would decide placement itself.
Instead of funding Act 20, DPI wants a new $13M grant tied to “alignment” with DPI’s own statewide literacy plan. Conveniently, for Underly, that plan is still listed as “Under Construction” on their website. They want money tied to a plan nobody has seen while abandoning the popular and results-driven Act 20 law because Underly deemed it “rigid.”
Meanwhile, about $25M in Act 20 reading money is expected to lapse back to the state on June 30, 2027. DPI spent just $1.9M on Act 20 teacher training reimbursements, blamed the law, and now asks for new money under its own rules. Make no mistake, this is a bureaucratic maneuver to end a widely popular Act 20 law and replace it with Underly’s “Under Construction” state literacy plan.
The new literacy grant doesn’t fund the schools where kids are failing most. It funds schools that can show a “gap” between student subgroups. DPI frames the whole thing around racial gaps. Rewarding gaps, not results.
Buried in “Miscellaneous Statutory Requests,” the Foundations of Reading Test for new teachers would be repealed. One line, no explanation. More literacy money, less oversight, and fewer reading standards for the people teaching it.
Math
Republicans tried an Act 20 for math, AB 615, with screeners and intervention plans for kids falling behind. It died in committee. DPI’s answer? Its own “statewide math plan,” which it calls “not a mandate” but usage is directly tied to grant funding.
The plan’s writers say the goal is “creativity, curiosity and joy,” and that math “shouldn’t be judged solely on test scores or standards.” DPI’s math newsletter pushes “productive struggle” and “math identity.” While half our kids are below grade level in math, Underly and her budget request focus on math as a human, exploratory pursuit, instead of intentional math facts and skills building curriculum.
Here’s the catch: DPI’s new $13M math grant requires schools to align with these DPI plans of math goals based on “creativity, curiosity and joy.” So a plan that’s “not a mandate” becomes the price of admission for state money and zero phonics-style guardrails, just Madison’s vision and vibes. The criteria for this plan? “Strategies for a positive learning culture,” scoring to be written later by DPI rulemaking and run by unnamed “partner organizations,” and it doesn’t start until FY29, after the 2028 election.
Other Controls
More Madison control nudges buried within the budget. The State Superintendent gets power to approve and revoke charter authorizers. $2M for an unnamed contractor to recommend district consolidations. Revenue limits rising automatically with inflation, with no reading results attached.
DPI also promises new “accountability” rules for choice schools, “in a separate document.” They haven’t released it. The rules that matter most to choice families aren’t in the budget at all. What could possibly go wrong by giving DPI more unchecked power?
Libraries, Staff, and Extras
Libraries are next. In-person visits are down 37% since 2010, from 35.2M to 22.8M. Computer sessions are down 77%. Reference questions, down 47%. One thing that isn’t down is library staff, which rose from 3,207 in 2010 to 3,290 in 2024. DPI still wants state library aid at $31M, double 2017’s $15.5M.
Meanwhile, the books get squeezed. After inflation, library spending on books and materials is down 26% since 2010. Print is down 40%. Libraries now spend about $8 on staff for every $1 on books. Library usage is down, while payroll is up. That’s not a library plan. It’s a jobs program.
And the fastest-growing library contract? A 46% raise for UW’s children’s book center, the group that trains librarians to keep challenged books on the shelf while parents’ complaints are reviewed. No usage numbers or results are attached.
DPI wants $12.5M to modernize its own IT. Its words: today’s grant process is “manual,” “fragmented,” and “error-prone.” Fair enough. Every business that automates expects savings. It even pairs the new grant software with a new staffer to help schools use it.
DPI has 638 positions. The last budget’s “cuts” were expiring federal jobs. State-funded staff stayed flat at 247. And the $1M IT line becomes permanent.
DPI says $13-$18 student club dues are a “barrier,” and it admits it has no data to prove any barriers exist. Don’t worry, they’ve found a problem that they can’t prove is a problem and put a price tag on it. The fix: $6 MILLION a year, half for dues, the rest for things like “Professional attire support.” $12 million over two years.
Taxpayers shouldn’t be buying kids’ student clubs clothes. That’s not access. It’s a giveaway.
The Document Itself
A multi-billion-dollar request still contains “INSERT FUNDING TABLE HERE,” a 2021-23 header, an internal staff email note (“The numbers from prior years which I sent you Friday…”), a figure typed as “$13,7000,” and basic arithmetic failures. DPI’s “equity” case for GED aid says 2,477 of 5,435 is 59 percent. It is 45.6 percent. Another row calls 791 of 1,330 “38 percent.” It is 59.5 percent. They want to manage billions more in funding and did not check their own math.
DPI has 159 open educator license investigations, some from complaints up to three years old, plus 60 more complaints it hasn’t even evaluated. DPI’s fix is to keep license-fee money that currently goes to the general fund.
Underly posted a budget roll-out video on Friday and limited replies to accounts she follows. It has been seen more than 150,000 times.
Bottom Line
Billions more. The Special Needs Scholarship is closed to every future child. Choice payments are frozen and cut for high-schoolers while public districts get larger automatic increases. Private schools written out of doubled mental-health money. Act 20 treated as rigid and replaced with money tied to a plan no one has seen. The teacher’s reading test was repealed in one unexplained line. Math is reduced to “joy.” Libraries run more like a jobs program. A request with 78 spelling and formatting errors and filed after voters had already gone to the polls.
Local control only if you agree with Underly and Madison. The door slamming shut on the kids who need out of the system.
