Milwaukee has spent years struggling with an infant mortality crisis, with dozens of babies dying before reaching their first birthday each year. To combat the problem, Wisconsin taxpayers have poured millions of dollars into Medicaid-funded prenatal care programs designed to help vulnerable mothers access the resources they need to deliver healthy babies.
Milwaukee County Executive and Governor-elect David Crowley has long advocated for directing Medicaid dollars to prenatal care organizations to address the crisis. In October, Crowley called to expand Medicaid coverage for prenatal services, doulas, and postpartum care as part of his agenda.
But instead of helping save lives, millions of dollars in Medicaid funding intended to support vulnerable mothers and their babies in Milwaukee County have wound up lining the pockets of fraudsters who exploited the program for their own financial gain.
Three more individuals have been charged in connection with the growing scandal, adding to an already lengthy list of Milwaukee-area prenatal care operators accused of stealing taxpayer dollars through fraudulent billing, falsified records, and illegal kickbacks.
According to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, more than a dozen individuals connected to prenatal care companies have faced criminal charges since widespread fraud within the program first came to light in 2022.
And the latest allegations suggest the problem was far from isolated.
Millions More in Alleged Fraud
Among the latest defendants is Detra Ferguson, owner of Direct Care Prenatal, who was indicted by a federal grand jury on November 3. Federal prosecutors allege Ferguson’s company improperly collected more than $2 million in Medicaid payments between 2018 and 2022.
Rather than simply providing prenatal care services, Ferguson allegedly used social media to recruit Medicaid recipients with promises of cash and free baby supplies, then submitted fraudulent claims for services that were never provided.
In one particularly egregious allegation, the company reportedly billed Medicaid for services supposedly provided to a recipient who had already died.
Ferguson now faces multiple federal charges, including health care fraud, aggravated identity theft, and unlawful monetary transactions.
Meanwhile, LaTonya Baker and Grisel Delgado were indicted in October in connection with another Milwaukee prenatal care operation, Generation of Excellence. Prosecutors allege Baker helped orchestrate a scheme that improperly collected more than $9.4 million in Medicaid payments between 2019 and 2023.
The operation allegedly relied on falsified billing records, kickbacks to recruit Medicaid recipients, and financial incentives encouraging employees to inflate the number of services they claimed to provide.
Altogether, the businesses submitted more than $11.8 million in claims containing allegedly fraudulent information.
Baker’s attorney has disputed the allegations.
The latest charges are only the latest chapter in a scandal that has already resulted in multiple guilty pleas and lengthy prison sentences.
Earlier this year, Markita Barnes, who operated Here for You Prenatal Care Coordination Services, was sentenced to more than 10 years in federal prison for stealing approximately $2.3 million from the prenatal care program.
During her sentencing, federal Judge Pamela Pepper highlighted the consequences of the widespread fraud, noting that Wisconsin had been forced to scale back the program so significantly that many women who genuinely needed the services could no longer access them.
In other words, the fraud didn’t just cost taxpayers millions. It helped deprive vulnerable mothers and their babies of the very resources the program was created to provide.
Barnes is hardly alone.
LaKia Jackson received a five-year prison sentence for stealing approximately $2.6 million, while Precious Cruse was sentenced to more than nine years for a scheme involving nearly $780,000.
More recently, Jasmine Cooper, a former owner of Bundle of Love Prenatal, pleaded guilty in July to federal charges stemming from another multimillion-dollar fraud scheme. As The Heartland Post previously reported, Cooper’s case was part of a nationwide crackdown on health care fraud.
Another former Bundle of Love owner, Candy Gandy, pleaded guilty in September in connection with more than $5.4 million in improper Medicaid payments. As part of her plea agreement, Gandy agreed to forfeit millions of dollars, three custom Rolex watches, and several pieces of expensive jewelry, including a diamond Jesus pendant.
Just earlier this month, The Heartland Post reported that Caprice Mathies-Hill, owner of Abby’s Clubhouse, was charged with submitting more than $1 million in fraudulent Medicaid claims and collecting more than $470,000 in improper payments.
Taxpayers Pay the Price
The sheer scale of the fraud raises serious questions about how so many operators were able to collect millions of dollars from Medicaid before authorities intervened.
In 2023, state health officials revealed that, during a roughly five-month period, more than $2 million in prenatal care claims had been submitted, but only approximately $20,000 was determined to be legitimate.
That’s less than one percent.
And while federal prosecutors have continued bringing charges against those accused of exploiting the system, the damage extends well beyond the money stolen.
Milwaukee has long struggled with high infant mortality rates, particularly among Black infants, who are significantly more likely to die before their first birthday than white infants. These prenatal care programs were supposed to help address that crisis by connecting expectant mothers with health care, counseling, education, and other critical resources.
Instead, the program became the target of repeated fraud schemes involving millions of taxpayer dollars, ultimately contributing to cuts that limited access for the very families it was intended to serve.
Programs like these can become attractive targets for fraudsters when millions of taxpayer dollars are distributed with inadequate oversight. By operating under the guise of helping vulnerable mothers and children, bad actors can exploit the public’s trust in these programs, betting that few will question where the money is actually going or whether the services being billed for are ever provided.
As the list of defendants continues to grow, one question remains: How many more millions of dollars intended to help save babies’ lives were allowed to disappear before anyone put a stop to it?
