MPS was supposed to finalize a list of schools to close or merge, instead they created a wish list of new ideas for the district.
Some months ago, the Great Schools Committee for Milwaukee Public Schools (MPS) was tasked primarily with creating a list of schools to close or merge. This list was supposed to be given to the MPS school board by the end of November. However at Monday night’s meeting, the committee did not finalize a list of recommended school closings or mergers.
The Heartland Post noted that Perkins Eastman Consulting and MPS discussions had identified 13 schools that could potentially be closed or merged because of low enrollment and underuse. At the meeting “MPS officials asked the committee to “dream big” about how to transform district facilities, asking where they’d like to see new schools, renovations and program expansions.” according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
At Monday’s final scheduled Great Schools Committee meeting, community members weren’t simply talking about which buildings should close. They were weighing ideas about rebuilding schools, renovating facilities, expanding programs and rethinking what the MPS footprint should look like in the future.
What happened to the urgency of shrinking MPS to fit the number of students it actually serves and to deal with the budget deficit?
The Great Schools committee instead supported improving or replacing aging buildings. There was significant interest in growing MPS Montessori programs, building more community schools and transportation shuttles for students. Some participants advocated constructing new buildings or adding on to existing buildings before existing schools are closed.
The Great Schools process started against the backdrop of enrollment decline, underused buildings and serious financial pressures. The earlier Heartland Post report noted that MPS was operating roughly 149 buildings while enrollment had fallen from 78,000 students in 2008 to 55,000 in 2025.
The committee was designed specifically to create a list of potential school closures or mergers. However the meeting sounded more like a Christmas list rather than a plan to deal with declining enrollment and budget constraints.
The timing of this sudden evolution deserves scrutiny. Democrats now control the governor’s office and legislature, fundamentally changing the political landscape in Madison. Now MPS is talking about dreaming big, building schools, renovating facilities and expanding programs instead of producing the closure recommendations Milwaukee was expecting. MPS is betting that the new political power structure will mean more money from the state and/or another referendum.
Before talking about building schools and expanding services, MPS should be living within its means and dealing with its reality. MPS’s enrollment is less than half of all schools in the city of Milwaukee.
The Great Schools Committee was supposed to help MPS confront difficult choices, not create a new list of wants. Milwaukee does not need tough choices piled beneath an ever growing list of things everyone would like to have.
MPS still has aging buildings. It still has fewer students than it once did. It still has underused schools. And it still has to decide whether maintaining all of those buildings makes financial and educational sense. The reporting Monday says those closure decisions have not yet been made.
So before MPS asks Milwaukee to “dream big,” perhaps the district should stick to the problem at hand.
