When 15% of Black Students Reading at Grade Level is “Meeting Expectations,” We Need To Expect More
In Wisconsin's largest school district, just 14.9% of Black students are reading at grade level. The state's Department of Public Instructions says this "Meets Expectations."
Fresh off its ridiculous $2.75 billion budget request that would consume more than 80% of Wisconsin’s existing state surplus, the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI) released its latest round of school report cards, grading zero school districts as “Fails to Meet Expectations.”
In fact, 95% of Wisconsin school districts received a passing grade, even as roughly half of students statewide failed to demonstrate proficiency in reading or math.
In Milwaukee Public Schools, which has long been one of the worst-performing urban school districts in America despite the district receiving roughly $24,000 per student, the district’s star rating grew from 2 stars to 3, meaning they now “Meet Expectations” in the eyes of the state’s education bureaucracy.
If taken at face value, this would be cause for celebration—a sign of progress in Wisconsin’s largest school district, which has failed its students, particularly Black and Hispanic students, for decades.
But as is often the case with DPI’s report cards, the devil is in the details. And those details paint yet another heartbreaking picture of students being consistently let down by the adults in charge.
The Numbers Tell a Different Story
According to DPI’s latest report card, less than a quarter of MPS students are reading at the state’s proficiency standard, while just over 20% meet that standard in math. The numbers are even worse when you look at Black students, who make up nearly half of the district’s student body.
In Milwaukee Public Schools, only 14.9% of Black students meet or exceed the state’s reading standard, while just over 10% are proficient in math.
The racial achievement gap is staggering, but unsurprising in a state that has consistently ranked among the worst in the country for disparities between Black and white students.
In MPS, white students are more than four times as likely to meet the state’s reading standard, with 63.2% meeting or exceeding expectations in English Language Arts. In math, just over half of white students are proficient, roughly five times the rate of their Black peers.
Even students classified as English learners (non-native English speakers) performed slightly better in reading than Black students overall, with 17.1% meeting or exceeding the state’s standard.
The problems extend well beyond reading and math.
Nearly half of all MPS students—46.2%—are considered chronically absent, compared to the statewide average of 17.5%. Among African American students, that number climbs to an astonishing 58.3%. Wisconsin defines chronic absenteeism as missing more than 10% of enrolled school days. In a traditional 180-day school year, that means missing more than 18 days of instruction.
It’s hard for students to learn if they aren’t physically in the classroom to begin with.
MPS and DPI frequently point to improving graduation rates as evidence of success. And on paper, those numbers do look encouraging. Over the last five school years, MPS’s four-year graduation rate increased from 63.8% to 72.2%, while the rate among African American students grew from 58.4% to 67.1%.
In isolation, that’s positive news—until you look back at the reading and math scores.
When fewer than 15% of Black students demonstrate reading proficiency, but 67.1% are graduating, the math ain’t mathing.
A diploma should represent more than simply making it through four years of high school. It should signify that a student has developed the skills necessary to succeed in college, the workforce, and everyday life.
Passing more students through the system without ensuring they have the academic skills necessary to succeed after they leave isn’t something worth celebrating. It’s another example of the adults in charge lowering expectations and giving up on students rather than helping kids reach their full potential.
While Democrats and public education bureaucrats are quick to point out supposed systemic racism everywhere in society—including beer gardens and golf courses—they continue to overlook one of the most systemically racist institutions in Wisconsin: underperforming urban public schools.
More heartbreaking than the scores themselves is the fact that our state’s education bureaucracy believes a district where fewer than 15% of Black students demonstrate reading proficiency deserves a rating of “Meets Expectations.”
Rather than treating these numbers as the five-alarm fire they are, DPI awards MPS a passing grade. Frankly, it’s insulting.
This is what the soft bigotry of low expectations looks like in real time: an education system so accustomed to poor outcomes that it has seemingly accepted them as the standard.
Students who leave school without basic literacy and math skills face enormous obstacles in pursuing higher education, finding meaningful employment, and escaping generational poverty. We should demand more for these children, not congratulate the system for producing marginal improvements while the overwhelming majority continue to struggle.
How DPI Moves the Goalposts
So how does DPI justify giving Milwaukee Public Schools a rating of “Meets Expectations” despite these numbers? The answer lies in how the department calculates its report cards.
DPI has repeatedly changed the standards used to measure student performance, creating a system in which reported achievement can improve without corresponding improvements in what students actually know.
In 2024, DPI lowered proficiency thresholds on state assessments, making it easier for students to receive a passing designation. The following year, the department revised the scoring ranges used to assign school and district report card ratings.
Internal DPI communications obtained by the Institute for Reforming Government revealed that department officials had been warned the changes could artificially inflate proficiency rates and report card scores.
In an April 2024 analysis, DPI’s own Office of Educational Accountability warned that higher reported proficiency could increase school ratings so dramatically that there would be little meaningful distinction between schools.
Republican lawmakers subsequently introduced legislation to restore the proficiency standards established when Governor Tony Evers led DPI, but Evers vetoed the measure.
And that’s only part of the equation.
Under Wisconsin’s report card formula, districts with higher concentrations of economically disadvantaged students are evaluated more heavily on academic growth than overall achievement.
There’s certainly value in recognizing growth. But growth should never become an excuse for ignoring what students are showing they are and are not capable of.
In MPS, academic achievement accounts for just 5% of the overall report card calculation, while academic growth accounts for 45%. That means the district’s actual proficiency levels receive far less emphasis than its students’ year-to-year academic progress.
MPS’s reading proficiency increased from 24.1% to 24.9%, an improvement that is closer to statistical insignificance than substantial growth. Yet despite receiving an academic achievement score of just 35.3 out of 100, MPS walks away with a passing report card.
DPI can celebrate improvements in growth, adjust its scoring formulas, and congratulate districts for meeting expectations. But none of that changes how many students are leaving school without the skills they need to succeed.
More Money, Fewer Options
So what’s DPI’s plan to address these failures?
According to its latest budget request, the department wants billions more in taxpayer funding while pursuing policies that would restrict educational alternatives for the very students being underserved.
DPI is proposing a massive overhaul of Wisconsin’s school funding formula, redirecting billions in existing funding while seeking substantial additional spending. Of course, more funding is hardly a new solution. Milwaukee Public Schools already receives roughly $24,000 per student, yet academic outcomes remain alarmingly low.
Even more concerning are DPI’s proposals to phase out the Special Needs Scholarship Program and restrict funding increases for Wisconsin’s school choice programs.
For decades, school choice has provided thousands of low-income Milwaukee families—particularly Black families—with an opportunity to pursue an education outside their assigned public schools. Today, less than half of Milwaukee students actually attend MPS while roughly 30,000 Milwaukee students attend private choice schools, nearly half of whom are Black.
These are families who have already decided that the status quo isn’t good enough for their children, even when the educational bureaucracy tells them that it is.
Yet rather than expanding those opportunities, DPI wants to phase out a scholarship program serving thousands of students with disabilities and impose new financial restrictions on private school choice.
The department also wants to weaken provisions of Wisconsin’s Act 20 literacy reforms, which brought phonics-based Science of Reading instruction into classrooms, following the example of states like Mississippi that have made significant gains in reading achievement.
In an internal email during the debate over literacy reforms, State Superintendent Jill Underly complained about “all this other nonsense going on with literacy” and seemingly dismissed the reforms altogether. In her most recent State of Education Address, Underly did not mention the words “literacy” or “reading” once.
Now, with reading scores still alarmingly low, her department wants to replace or loosen key requirements of the state’s literacy law while directing additional funding toward programs aligned with DPI’s own undetermined plans.
If the priorities seem backward, it’s because they are.
Rather than strengthening academic expectations, expanding parental options, and ensuring existing taxpayer dollars produce better results, DPI continues to focus on more spending, more bureaucratic control, and changes to the standards used to measure success.
Wisconsin’s Children Deserve Better
Every student who makes genuine academic progress deserves to be celebrated. But there’s a difference between recognizing progress and declaring victory.
The purpose of our education system isn’t to produce impressive-looking report cards, protect bureaucracies, or justify the next multibillion-dollar budget request. It’s to educate children and prepare them for success beyond the classroom.
When fewer than 15% of Black students in our state’s largest district meet reading proficiency standards, yet the district receives a passing grade, something is fundamentally wrong with how we define success.
We shouldn’t be lowering expectations to make our schools look better or make the adults in charge of them feel better. We should be raising expectations to give our students a better future.
Wisconsin’s children deserve more than a passing grade for a failing status quo. They deserve an education system that actually expects them to succeed.