After a general election, there is a sense of relief with having another election season behind us. Wisconsin always has a contested election cycle and it can be extremely draining. Unfortunately, Wisconsinites only know that feeling of relief for a fleeting moment. Spring elections are just around the corner. To put it lightly, I’m tired.
As a conservative voter, I’m tired of the trend of hoping for the best and watching spring elections get worse by the year. Will this year be any different than the previous ones? I’m not sure, but I’m extremely concerned that we are sleepwalking into a much worse situation than normal.
The history since Brian Hagedorn’s razor-thin 2019 win is not encouraging. Hagedorn edged Lisa Neubauer by half a point and remains the last conservative to win a contested race for the high court. Since then the results have been a steady march left: Jill Karofsky in 2020, Janet Protasiewicz in 2023 (the race that flipped the court to a 4-3 liberal majority), Susan Crawford in 2025, and Chris Taylor’s 20-point blowout over Maria Lazar in 2026 that expanded the majority to 5-2.
These are not encouraging results or trends. I guess there is some solace that we are reaching a point where there is nowhere to go but up. That being said, the court has a solid liberal majority for years to come and we have to stop the bleeding at some point. When is that point? Democrats are coming off their best midterm since Watergate. Are they due for a letdown? I’m not so sure this is the case.
After many disappointing elections, even I momentarily forgot that a Supreme Court election was on the horizon. Democrats are certainly aware of it. They already have a competitive primary for the open seat being vacated by Annette Ziegler between Clark County Circuit Judge Lyndsey Brunette (announced April 16) and Milwaukee Court of Appeals Judge Pedro Colón (announced April 28). Both are liberals with prior Democratic ties. This primary has been running for more than seven months already. While we have been recovering from the fall results, they have been organizing, fundraising, and locking in support.
Because of the new electorate and voting trends, Republicans start at a disadvantage in spring elections. Currently, there are no declared candidates to run and represent the conservative side. Time is ticking, and every week that someone doesn’t announce means another week that liberals maintain that built-in advantage.
As a movement, I do think we have to have an honest conversation: if someone doesn’t announce by Christmas, and certainly by the New Year, we may not contest the Supreme Court election at all. The filing deadline is early January. Building a viable statewide campaign takes months, not weeks. We can’t afford to lose any time.
This is not an attempt to demoralize our side, but simply a reality that we are facing. What is the incentive for a judge to run after looking at the last election results? If you are superstitious, the silver lining is that the last uncontested Supreme Court election was in 2017, when Annette Ziegler ran unopposed.
That was a different court and a different political environment. Since 2019, Democrats are on a tear with little evidence of slowing down. Maybe the inverse will occur? History suggests otherwise until we actually field a candidate who is willing to run like the stakes matter.
Regardless of whether we have a Supreme Court candidate to vote for or not, we still need to be involved and vote for local trustees and school board candidates. Those races still matter for the people who show up. In the meantime, let’s hope that a brave candidate comes forward to throw their hat in the ring and start flipping the narrative on spring elections in Wisconsin.
The alternative is another uncontested or lightly contested seat that locks in a 6-1 liberal majority for the better part of a decade. We have seen what that looks like. It is time to stop sleepwalking.
