Ninety-five percent of Wisconsin public school districts met or beat state expectations on report cards the Department of Public Instruction released Tuesday. DPI’s own test data show about half of public school students aren’t proficient in reading or math.
DPI’s district data file shows 358 of 377 districts landed in the top three rating categories. The other 19, or 5%, were rated “Meets Few Expectations.” For another year, not one district was rated “Fails to Meet Expectations.”
Schools fared nearly as well. Of 1,904 scored public schools, 1,626, or 85%, met expectations or better. Only 61, about 3%, failed, according to DPI’s school data file.
Test scores from the same school year tell a different story. In grades 3 through 11, 49.7% of public school students were proficient or above in English and 50.2% in math, DPI announced October 1.
The report card data show 133 of the 358 districts rated “Meets Expectations,” or higher, had fewer than half their students meeting the state’s English standard. Twenty districts rated “Exceeds” or “Significantly Exceeds” were also below 50%. West Allis-West Milwaukee earned four stars with 39.6% of students proficient in English and 32.6% proficient in math.
The biggest mover was Milwaukee Public Schools. MPS scored 59.5 and was rated “Meets Few Expectations” last year. This year it scored 60.6, just above the 60-point line, and DPI moved the state’s largest district up to “Meets Expectations.”
According to the data file, 24.9% of MPS students met the English standard and 20.3% met the math standard. Just 22% of MPS third graders were proficient in reading.
MPS posted gains. English proficiency in grades 3 through 8 rose from 23.6% to 25.1%. “I’m not spiking the football today, but I am giving credit where credit is due because progress matters,” Superintendent Brenda Cassellius told WPR in October.
The rating formula leans on growth in high-poverty districts. Under state law, DPI weights achievement and growth by poverty. In districts where at least 65% of students are economically disadvantaged, growth gets a 0.9 multiplier and achievement gets 0.1, according to DPI’s technical guide. At MPS, that share is 79.6%. Its achievement score was 35.3 out of 100.
The bar for proficiency has also moved. In 2024, DPI lowered the threshold for proficiency on the Forward Exam and dropped labels like “basic” and “below basic.” Even Gov. Tony Evers said the change “could have been handled better.” The Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty testified last year that the new cut scores raised reported proficiency by 8 to 10% with no real gain in learning.
In summer 2025, a 26-member panel reset the report card rating ranges, and State Superintendent Jill Underly adopted them without changes. DPI says scores since then cannot be directly compared to earlier years. But the share of districts rated “Exceeds” or better has climbed from 36 percent in 2023-24 to 52 percent this year, according to DPI’s report card data files.
The national test scores are lower still. On the 2024 Nation’s Report Card, 31% of Wisconsin fourth graders were proficient in reading and 37% of eighth graders were proficient. Will Flanders, research director at WILL, called the zero-failure result “absurd” Tuesday, “in a state where many kids can’t read.” He also posted a list of districts rated “Meets Expectations” or higher with English proficiency below 35%. The DPI data show nine. show nine.
DPI has defended the weighting. “Schools serving higher percentages of economically disadvantaged students are weighted more heavily toward growth, while schools that are maybe serving fewer of those students are weighted more toward achievement,” communications director Chris Bucher told WPR last year.
This year, DPI said the results reflect the dedication of educators, staff, families, and communities and show schools need reliable, sustainable resources. Underly said in October that “too many students are still not where they need to be.”
Underly’s department is asking for roughly $2.75 billion in new aid for schools and libraries in the 2027-29 budget. Gov.-elect David Crowley and the new Democratic Legislature will decide how much of it to fund.
