Another city council just passed a policy that sounds innocent enough: add a flyer to property tax bills showing taxpayers how much their taxes fund school choice programs. It’s being sold as “transparency.”
Don’t believe it.
What happened in yet another Wisconsin community is part of a coordinated campaign by public school advocates to chip away at education freedom through the backdoor. And unfortunately, it’s working. Similar votes have already passed in Sheboygan and Green Bay, with Lake Mills now following suit. More cities will be targeted by these political activists. The pattern is unmistakable, and the message is calculated: Your money is going to students who aren’t in traditional public schools. Shouldn’t you be angry about that?
This coordinated effort raises an important question: If school choice is really so harmful to students and communities, why do its opponents need to rely on accounting tricks instead of simply making their case with facts?
For the families who are served by the school choice program, these gains represent transformational opportunities for the next generation.
Perhaps, because the facts don’t back up their claims. Recent peer-reviewed research from the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty analyzed over 100,000 Wisconsin students between 2018-19 and 2022-23, and the results are striking. Students who remained in Wisconsin’s private school choice programs for four years or more made reading gains equivalent to more than one additional year of education compared to similar public school students.
When you control for income, race, disability status, and other demographic factors, the picture becomes even clearer: students in choice and charter schools show proficiency levels that are 4.1 percentage points higher in English Language Arts and 7.7 percentage points higher in math compared to their public school peers.
These aren’t marginal gains. For the families who are served by the school choice program, these gains represent transformational opportunities for the next generation.
So why are public school advocates pushing for these tax bill inserts? They’ll tell you it’s about transparency and making sure taxpayers know where their money goes. But if the goal were truly transparency, they’d be just as interested in explaining why families choose these programs, and how those students perform. They would want to share all per pupil spending and compare reading and math results.
But these activists are not interested in the truth or actual transparency. Their goal is narrower: to create resentment toward education freedom.
But these activists are not interested in the truth or actual transparency. Their goal is narrower: to create resentment toward education freedom. To make property taxpayers feel like victims. To blame private schools and choice students as the perpetrator. To suggest that school choice is a luxury or a mistake rather than what it actually is: a fundamental right of parents to direct their children’s education.
Parents should have the freedom to choose the school that best serves their child, regardless of their ZIP code or family income. That’s not a partisan value. It’s a basic principle of a free society. When government and teachers unions are in charge, they serve the interests of the system, not the interests of children.
The left’s coordinated push to shame taxpayers for funding school choice reveals something important about their position: they can’t win this debate on merit. They can’t explain why a parent shouldn’t be allowed to select a different educational environment for their child if the current system isn’t working. They can’t point to superior outcomes to justify their opposition.
So instead, they continue to organize at the local level, city council by city council, tax bill by tax bill, to gradually shift the political landscape against education freedom.
Defenders of education freedom and parents rights must start pushing back now. With a Democrat trifecta in Madison, and liberals controlling our State Supreme Court, we are the last line of defense for education freedom in our state. We cannot let activists, under the guise of transparency, fuel resentment towards school choice and create the policy environment to allow the Democrats to repeal these freedoms.
Pay attention to your city council and town board meetings. Push back against advocacy cloaked as transparency. And defend the right of every child to have the best education possible.
